A drug search can alter the course of a criminal prosecution. Police can uncover narcotics in a car, home, bag or even on a person’s body. But finding evidence doesn’t always guarantee the evidence can be used in court. But may a drug lawyer attack evidence from a drug search? Yes. A lawyer can check how the police stopped, searched and arrested you. If the police violated the law, your defense lawyer could urge the court to exclude some evidence. That can be a pretty big thing. Sometimes the evidence that can be challenged is the major evidence against you
Why the Search is Important
The Fourth Amendment protects persons from unwarranted searches and seizures. Police have regulations they must follow to look for evidence . Not everything can be so ruled. A search of a residence may pose different questions than a search of a car. A traffic stop may include distinct issues than a search incident to an arrest. And that’s why the details matter. A drug lawyer may ask:
- How did the cops pull you over?
- Did the officers have probable cause to search?
- Did they have a warrant to search?
- Did you consent to the search?
- Where did officers find the drugs?
- What was before the search?
- Did cops stay within the scope of the warrant?
These questions can identify flaws that are not apparent from an arrest record.
Did Police Have a Probable Cause for Search?
“The thing is, cops don’t always need a warrant. The legislation enables certain searches without one. For instance, in some cases there may be probable cause for the police. And they can also look for within particular exceptions allowed by law. But an officer’s belief alone is not enough. A lawyer can examine what the officer knew prior to the search. Timing can be important too. What did the cops see, hear or discover before opening the bag or searching the vehicle? Imagine an officer stops a driver for a minor traffic violation. Later, the officer examines the car and finds drugs. This does not dispose of all questions of law. A lawyer can review the circumstances of the search and whether the search was legal.
What if you said yes?
Consent can make a search permissible in some circumstances. But consent has its own questions. You really consented to the search? Did you provide consent freely? Did cops intimidate or pressure you? The facts matter exactly. Sometimes people believe they have no option when an officer asks to search. They can respond yes because they are anxious or confused. A lawyer can see what was said and done at the time of the request. “Don’t think you sign a paper or say ‘okay’ and that’s the end of the conversation. The circumstances do matter.
Search Warrants Have Their Rules
A search warrant does not give the police carte blanche. A warrant must identify the place to be searched and the evidence that police may look for. Officers are often required to work within those constraints. Seeking instance, assume the police have a warrant seeking a certain kind of evidence. No matter what the warrant allows, they cannot just search everyplace they can think of. A drug lawyer can look into the warrant, the affidavit that was used to get it, and how the officers went about conducting the search. If there is a severe legal concern, the defense can question the evidence.
What is Suppression of Evidence?
A lawyer would say, Motion to suppress. It is seeking the judge to stop certain evidence being used at trial in simple terms. The defense may allege that the police used an illegal search or seizure to get the evidence. Then the judge looks at the facts and the law that applies. If the motion is granted, the evidence may be suppressed. That doesn’t always settle the case. But it can make it much more difficult for the prosecution, especially if the evidence being disputed is fundamental to the charge. Think of a case like a jigsaw. Take away one large element and the whole picture can look different.
What if drugs are found in a car?
Drug searches involving vehicles can become complicated. The police may have different legal reasons to search a car than they would to search a residence. What the cops see, why they stop, and the conditions of the search can all be significant. The position of the medications makes a difference, too. Were they underneath your seat? In the boot? In a bag that is locked? “Did anybody else get into the car?” Possession of narcotics found in a vehicle occupied by several people does not immediately establish who had possession of the drugs. A lawyer may look at the whole picture, not just one fact.
So What About a Home Search?
The house is strongly protected by the Fourth Amendment. Generally, police need a warrant to search a home, unless there is a recognized exception to the warrant requirement. The circumstances of the entry and search can become quite critical. An attorney can look at how the officers entered the house, what they looked at, and what they found. Neighbors, family members, security footage, photographs and police body camera footage can help explain what happened, too. Sometimes the paperwork reveals a different narrative. The video says something else. That is why a complete case review is important.
Don’t Forget the Trail of Evidence
But that’s not the only problem with the search. They may also look at what transpired after the cops found the drugs. Who collected the stuff? What was its label? Where did they store it? Who did it before testing it? This is often referred to as the chain of custody. The prosecution wants good proof. If there are doubts about how the evidence was handled or tested, the defense may have a case to contest it. Again little nuances can make a difference.
Questions lead to a strong defense
A drug case is not won only by the arrest. The evidence and how the cops collected it matters. If you are charged with a crime, a competent Criminal Defense Lawyer can evaluate police reports, warrants, videos, witnesses accounts and other data. This helps the lawyer discover probable problems with the search and the evidence. David Benowitz is a criminal defense attorney with Platinum Criminal Defense Law Firm who represents clients charged with crimes around the United States. Rated AV by Martindale-Hubbell, Mr. Benowitz has also received a flawless 10 rating from AVVO. He is also a member of the National College of DUI Defense. Mr. Benowitz is faculty at Harvard Law School’s Trial Advocacy Workshop. If a challenge is made to the search for drugs, legal experience can make a difference.
What Happens After a Drug Search?
Don’t fight with police about the search afterward. Do not remove any correspondence or other records relevant to the case. Keep your papers. Save pertinent photos, videos and documents. Most important of all, don’t tell those who don’t need to know the facts of your situation. Then talk to an experienced criminal defense counsel. The more quickly your lawyer can review the search, the more quickly you will know your legal choices.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can a drug lawyer fight drugs detected in a police search?
Brief answer: Yes, if there is a legitimate reason to dispute the search or seizure.
Detail: A lawyer can investigate why cops searched you, your car, your home or any other place. If your rights were violated by cops, the defense might submit a motion to suppress the evidence. The judge decides if the evidence should be omitted.
- Do cops need a warrant to search for drugs?
Short answer: No, not always.
Detail : There are known exceptions to the requirement requiring a warrant. Sometimes police search based on probable cause, consent or other legal justification. The applicability of the exception depends on the facts surrounding the search.
- Suppose I consented to a drug search?
Short answer : Your permission might allow the search, but it still depends on the details.
Detail: A lawyer can look to see if you gave your consent freely and what the cops said to you before you did. Legal questions can arise when there is pressure, threats or other circumstances. Don’t think that by saying yes you’ll stop the problem right then.
- Can a lawyer contest a drug check of my car?
Short answer: Yes, you can dispute a car search if the law wasn’t followed.
Detail: The reason for the stop, what officers saw and why they searched can all be relevant. Your lawyer can also look into where the narcotics were found and if other people had access to the car.
- If the evidence of the drugs is suppressed, does it mean my case is dismissed?
Short answer: Not necessarily.
Detail: The court may prohibit specific evidence from being introduced at trial if evidence is suppressed. If that evidence is key to the prosecution’s case, the charge may become harder to prove. Other evidence may perhaps bolster the case.
Table of Contents